Iden Plans to Push Amended Internet Gaming Bill
Michigan State Representative Brandt Iden is not giving up. He plans to push his online poker and casino games bill in the legislature. And he’s doing the same with his separate sports betting bill.
On October 29, Iden introduced an amended bill for internet gaming legalization. Though he hasn’t come to any agreement with Governor Gretchen Whitmer, he made concessions in the bill to show a willingness to compromise. He hopes that she will do the same.
The Original Bills
Iden started the year by introducing the 2019 Lawful Internet Gaming Act – also known as HB.4311 – on March 7. He did so in conjunction with State Senator Curtis Hertel Jr., who introduced SB.0186 as a companion bill.
— Brandt Iden (@BrandtIden) March 13, 2019
There was some quick progress for Iden’s bill, which passed through the House Regulatory Reforms Committee with a 13-to-1 vote. It was then referred to the Ways and Means Committee.
Differences Become Clear
It was during Ways and Means hearings that the problem became clear.
The Michigan Department of Treasury issued an analysis of internet gaming legalization, one that Whitmer believed. It asserted that online poker and casino games would take revenue that would have otherwise gone to the School Aid Fund via the lottery and land-based gambling facilities.
Iden tried to submit New Jersey’s five-years-plus history of internet gaming as an example of how the games complement land-based properties, but Whitmer didn’t buy it.
Baby Steps of Negotiations
Iden’s original bill offered these essential numbers:
–$200,000 internet gaming license
–$100,000 annual license renewals
–8% tax on gross gaming revenue
Whitmer then proposed a staunchly different plan. The tiered tax rate would be based on revenue. Licensing fees would depend on the number of online slots offered by an operator, and their renewal fees each year would be based on revenue.
–8% tax rate for <$2.5M revenue, 16% for $2.5M-$4M, 32% for $4M-$8M, 40% tax for >$8M
–$200K license fee for <1,200 slots, $700K for 1,201-1,999 slots, $1M for >2,000 slots
–$175K renewal fee for <$2M revenue, $350K for $2M-$5M, $500K for >$5M
Iden called those numbers “non-starters” and not “meaningful.”
As first reported by @OPRupdate, Michigan online poker and igaming bills are stuck as @BrandtIden finds no willingness from Governor Whitmer to talk or negotiate. https://t.co/kkXzzVvmLr pic.twitter.com/sR3r4uQwv3
— LegalUSPokerSites (@legal_poker) July 28, 2019
New Numbers from Iden
Suddenly, on October 29, Iden produced a new version of HB.4311, the Lawful Internet Gaming Act.
Much of the 33-page bill was the same as when it was originally introduced, but Iden did offer some changes. The new numbers were:
–4% tax rate for <$4M, 6% for $4M-$8M, 8% for $8M-$10M, 10% for $10M-$12M, 19% for <$12M (all for first three years of operations)
–6% tax rate for <$4M, 8% for $4M-$8M, 10% for $8M-$10M, 12% for $10M-$12M, 21% for <$12M (for fourth year of operations)
–8% tax rate for <$4M, 10% for $4M-$8M, 12% for $8M-$10M, 14% for $10M-$12M, 23% for <$12M (for all years beyond the fourth)
–$100,000 internet licensing fee
–$50,000 annual license renewals
The day before Iden revealed his compromise bill, he spoke to the Detroit News about the process of negotiating with Whitmer. Essentially, he called them unsuccessful.
Iden stated that he reached out to Whitmer’s office several times to negotiate, but he was always told that everyone was too busy to discuss it.
House chair ready to throw dice on online gaming, sports betting bills by increasing tax rates on sports betting to 8.75% and online gaming to a tiered tax structure ranging from 4%-23% https://t.co/9woWSrLxBc via @detroitnews
— Beth LeBlanc (@DNBethLeBlanc) October 28, 2019
“It’s too bad that the folks have been too busy to engage,” Iden said, “but we have to move forward with the minimal amount of session days left.
Whitmer spokesperson Tiffany Brown said, “The administration has taken every meeting we’ve been invited to regarding this legislation, and we have continued to work closely with the bill sponsor, tribal leadership and stakeholders to attempt to address our concerns.”
As Iden noted, there are few session days remaining in 2019. The House only shows official session days as follows:
–December 17-19 (tentative)
The Senate shows the same but with two additional days on its calendar:
It can be done. Last year, Michigan’s online poker and casino games bill passed through the legislature on December 21.
Sure, one week later, outgoing Governor Rick Snyder vetoed it on the last Friday night of the year. But the point is that a bill can pass in the remaining days of the legislative calendar.
Michigan did it before. Iden did it before.
- Michigan Online Poker and Gambling Bill Moves to Senate
- Michigan Now Eyes Sports Betting with No Online Gaming
- No Movement in Michigan Online Poker Negotiations
- Michigan Governor Fights Online Gaming Efforts
- Former NJ Governor Urges Michigan to Follow His Lead
- Concerns Emerge About Michigan Internet Gaming Bill
- Confidence Holds for Michigan Internet Gaming Bill
- Michigan Online Gambling Bill Passes First Committee
- Michigan Shows Online Gaming Support in Committee Hearing
- Michigan Lawmakers Try Internet Gaming Bills Again